Healthcare fraud vs. abuse: Understanding the difference.
Key takeaways:
- Understanding the difference between healthcare fraud and abuse, then putting effective controls in place can help your organization identify potential issues earlier and protect its financial health.
- Billing patterns, payer audits and other data can help healthcare organizations spot potential issues early and determine where additional review may be needed.
- Strong compliance programs combine clear policies, employee training, monitoring and corrective action to help mitigate compliance risks and support long-term financial stability.
Healthcare organizations face a range of financial and operational risks — including billing errors, improper payments and intentional fraud.
For healthcare practice administrators, the issue goes beyond avoiding regulatory penalties. An investigation or enforcement action may disrupt cash flow, increase operating costs, affect relationships with payers and complicate access to financing.
Understanding the difference between healthcare fraud and abuse then putting effective controls in place can help you mitigate risks that can affect the financial health of your organization.
What is the difference between fraud and abuse in healthcare?
In healthcare, the key distinction between fraud and abuse generally comes down to intent — whether someone knowingly sought to deceive or obtain an improper benefit.
Generally, healthcare fraud involves intentional deception or misrepresentation to obtain an unauthorized benefit.
Abuse refers to practices that are inconsistent with sound fiscal, business or medical practices. These actions may result in unnecessary costs to Medicare or other payers, or in reimbursement for services that are not medically necessary, even when there is no evidence of an intent to deceive.
The distinction between fraud and abuse is important because the consequences can vary depending on the circumstances. In a healthcare organization, a billing error may be a compliance issue, while evidence of intentional misconduct can create additional legal and financial exposure.
Defining healthcare fraud.
Healthcare fraud can take many forms, but fraudulent activity generally involves obtaining payment or another benefit through intentional deception. These are some of the most common examples of healthcare fraud:
- Submitting a claim for a service that was never provided.
- Using a billing code associated with a more expensive or complex service than the one that was actually provided.
- Offering, paying, soliciting or receiving something of value in exchange for referrals or the ordering of services or products, which may implicate federal or state anti-kickback laws.
The financial consequences of fraud can extend beyond penalties or repayment. Depending on the circumstances, individuals and organizations may face civil or criminal penalties, exclusion from federal healthcare programs and significant costs associated with investigations and remediation.
Recognizing healthcare abuse.
Healthcare abuse can be more difficult to distinguish from billing errors or other compliance issues because it does not necessarily involve an intentional effort to deceive. Here are some potential examples:
- Providing services or tests that are not medically necessary.
- Using billing practices that are inconsistent with applicable rules or accepted medical or business practices.
- Unbundling services that should be billed together.
- Charging excessive fees for certain supplies or services.
- Failing to maintain adequate documentation to support claims.
For healthcare administrators, data can provide early warning signs. Unusual changes in billing activity, significant differences from peer benchmarks, or recurring issues identified through payer audits may warrant additional review.
How fraud and abuse can affect your organization’s financial health.
Healthcare fraud and abuse are legal and compliance concerns, but they can also have direct financial and operational effects on an organization.
- Cash flow disruptions: Payment holds, prepayment reviews, claim denials, repayments or other payer actions can slow the flow of revenue into an organization. For a healthcare organization that’s operating with tight margins, even a temporary disruption in cash flow can put pressure on working capital and debt-service obligations.
- Additional costs: Investigations often require internal staff time as well as outside legal, accounting and compliance resources. Organizations may also face repayment obligations, penalties and the cost of implementing corrective measures.
- Financing considerations: Lenders evaluate a variety of factors when assessing credit risk, including cash flow, financial performance and the stability of the business. A significant regulatory investigation or enforcement action can create additional questions about an organization’s future cash flow and operating stability that may need to be considered as part of financial planning or financing discussions.
- Reputational risk: Enforcement actions can also affect relationships with patients, employees, referral partners, payers, investors and other stakeholders. For organizations considering a merger, acquisition or expansion, compliance issues may be considered as part of the due diligence process.
Compliance is an important part of a healthcare organization’s broader risk-management strategy rather than a separate legal function.
Building fraud and abuse mitigation programs: Key compliance steps.
A strong compliance program can help your healthcare organization identify risks, establish accountability and respond promptly if problems arise.
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General’s General Compliance Program Guidance link opens in a new window outlines seven elements of an effective compliance program:
- Written policies and procedures that establish expectations and address areas of risk.
- Compliance leadership and oversight from organizational leadership and the board.
- Training and education appropriate to employees’ roles and responsibilities.
- Effective communication and reporting channels that allow employees to raise concerns.
- Consistent enforcement and discipline when violations occur.
- Auditing and monitoring of higher-risk activities and billing patterns.
- Prompt response and corrective action when potential problems are identified.
The size and complexity of an organization will influence how these elements are implemented. A small medical practice may rely on a more streamlined approach, while a large health system may require dedicated compliance personnel, data analytics and enterprise-wide training.
Insurance and financial protection in healthcare: Managing compliance risk.
Compliance is only one part of a healthcare organization’s broader risk-management strategy. Healthcare organizations can also evaluate whether their insurance coverage and financial controls align with the risks they face, as well as review their insurance coverage with qualified advisers to determine whether it addresses the risks relevant to their operations.
Regular reviews of internal financial controls can help identify weaknesses before they lead to larger issues. Segregating financial responsibilities, maintaining appropriate approval processes and regularly reconciling accounts can all help reduce opportunities for improper activities.
The role of compliance in financial risk management.
Healthcare organizations can strengthen their overall financial risk-management approach by documenting compliance policies, monitoring higher-risk activities and maintaining clear internal controls. When financing discussions require information about the organization’s financial or operational risk, those processes can also help demonstrate how the organization identifies and manages potential issues.
By treating compliance as part of financial and operational risk management, healthcare organizations can identify potential issues earlier, strengthen internal controls and better position themselves for long-term financial stability.
